For businesses in India, the choice between UPI and a Payment Gateway isn’t a simple comparison. It’s a strategic decision about how you want to accept payments, manage your transactions, and serve your customers. At its core, this is a choice between a direct payment method and a comprehensive payment platform.
This guide explains their distinct roles and helps you decide which approach, or combination, is best for your business model.
What is a Payment Gateway?
A Payment Gateway is a secure digital service that acts as a bridge between a customer, a merchant, and the bank to enable online payments.
In simple terms, when you pay for something online (say, via debit card, credit card, UPI, or net banking), the payment gateway:
- Captures the payment details (like card number, UPI ID, etc.) from the customer.
- Encrypts the information to keep it safe from fraud or misuse.
- Sends it securely to the bank or payment processor for authorization.
- Confirms approval or decline from the bank.
- Notifies the merchant and customer about the transaction status in real time.
Think of it like a digital “cashier” at an online store — it ensures money moves safely from your account to the seller’s account.
Types of Payment Gateway
Hosted Payment Gateway
- Customers are redirected from the merchant’s website or app to a secure checkout page hosted by the payment gateway.
- Pros: Very secure and easy to set up as the gateway handles the entire process.
- Limitation: Customer leaves the website temporarily during payment.
Self-Hosted Payment Gateway
- Customers enter payment details directly on the merchant’s website, which are then securely sent to the payment gateway for processing.
- Pros: The checkout experience remains on the merchant’s website, offering more brand consistency.
- Limitation: Merchants need to ensure proper data handling standards.
API-Based Gateway
- The payment gateway integrates with the website or app through APIs, allowing customers to complete payments without leaving the platform.
- Pros: Seamless and highly customizable experience for customers.
- Limitation: Merchants need stronger technical and security compliance measures
Mobile Payment Gateway
- Designed specifically for mobile or in-app transactions, supporting methods like UPI, wallets, and cards in a mobile-friendly way.
- Pros: Quick, user-friendly, and optimized for mobile-first experiences.
- Limitation: May need regular updates to match evolving mobile technologies.
In short:
- Hosted = Redirect checkout.
- Self-Hosted = Merchant collects data, gateway processes.
- API-Based = Gateway works in the background.
- Mobile = Optimized for app payments.
The Direct Path: UPI Without a Gateway
When you use a UPI app like Paytm to scan a QR code at a local store or send money to a friend, you are using UPI directly. In this scenario, the transaction is handled entirely by the UPI infrastructure, which is managed by the NPCI.
How It Works
- Initiation: The customer scans the merchant’s UPI QR code or enters their UPI ID.
- Routing: The UPI app sends a request through the NPCI UPI “switch.”
- Authentication: The customer’s bank (the PSP bank) authenticates the transaction using the customer’s UPI PIN.
- Completion: Funds are transferred instantly from the customer’s account to the merchant’s bank account.
Key Advantages for Businesses
- Zero Cost: For many small merchants, accepting UPI payments directly comes with zero Merchant Discount Rate (MDR), as per government policy. This is the most cost-effective way to accept digital payments.
- Instant Settlement: Funds are credited to your bank account in real-time. This provides immediate access to cash flow, which is critical for small businesses.
- Minimal Setup: All you need is a bank account and a printed QR code. There is no complex technical integration or monthly fee.
This direct approach is ideal for small businesses, street vendors, and local shops with a physical presence. It simplifies payment collection and eliminates processing fees.
The Platform Approach: Integrating UPI Through a Payment Gateway
For online businesses, e-commerce stores, and mobile apps, a payment gateway is a crucial component of the checkout process. In this case, UPI is not used directly but is offered as one of many payment options within the gateway’s unified checkout flow.
How It Works
- Initiation: A customer on a merchant website selects “Pay with UPI” at checkout.
- Request Generation: The payment gateway’s technology generates a dynamic UPI payment request (an “intent” link or a dynamic QR code) that is specific to the transaction amount and order details.
- Routing: The customer is redirected to their UPI app to complete the transaction. The payment gateway facilitates this seamless handoff and provides a secure channel for the transaction data.
- Confirmation: Once the transaction is completed via the NPCI network, the payment gateway receives confirmation and updates the merchant’s website, marking the order as paid.
Key Advantages for Businesses
- Unified Checkout Experience: A payment gateway provides a single, professional interface for all payment options, including UPI, credit/debit cards, net banking, and wallets. This reduces friction and can increase conversion rates.
- Automated Reconciliation: The gateway’s dashboard automates the entire payment management process. It tracks every transaction, handles refunds, and generates reports, saving valuable time and effort for the business.
- Enhanced Features: A payment gateway provides tools for subscription management, recurring billing, and advanced analytics, which are essential for scaling an online business.
- Simplified Compliance: As regulated entities, payment gateways handle the complex security and compliance requirements (like PCI-DSS), reducing the burden on the merchant.
Making the Strategic Choice
So, should small businesses use UPI or a payment gateway? The decision comes down to your business model. Here’s a quick costs comparison UPI vs payment gateway and a functional summary:
| Feature | UPI (Direct Path) | Payment Gateway (Platform Approach) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use Case | In-person payments (QR codes), simple online checkouts | E-commerce, websites, mobile apps, businesses needing multiple payment options |
| Transaction Cost | Zero MDR for many merchants | Incurs transaction fees (e.g., a percentage of the transaction amount) |
| Settlement Time | Real-time (Instant credit) | As per agreement, typically T+1 or T+2 working days (though UPI component can be instant) |
| Functionality | Simple payment collection via QR, UPI ID, or intent links | Comprehensive dashboard with analytics, automated reconciliation, invoicing, and refund management |
| Security | High security with UPI PIN and no sharing of bank account details | Adheres to RBI’s strict security and data storage guidelines (e.g., PCI-DSS compliance) |
| Complexity | Very low setup and technical requirements | Requires API integration for websites/apps, along with KYC and documentation |
| Best For | Small businesses, street vendors, local shops | Online businesses, e-commerce stores, apps, and enterprises |
This approach is essential for any business with an online presence, including e-commerce stores, apps, and SaaS companies. It professionalizes the checkout process and provides the necessary tools for transaction management.
In modern business, the lines are often blurred. Many payment gateways now offer simple QR code solutions for offline businesses, giving them the best of both worlds—the simplicity of UPI and the power of a managed platform. The key is to choose a solution that aligns with your operational needs and provides the best possible experience for your customers.
Author
