Section 43B was introduced in the Income Tax Act, 1961, to make sure businesses and taxpayers claim certain deductions only when they make actual payments. Earlier, many businesses followed the “accrual system” of accounting, where expenses were recorded when they became due—even if the money wasn’t paid. This led to tax benefits without actual outflow of funds.
To plug this loophole, Section 43B was inserted. It ensures deductions for specific expenses can be claimed only when the payment is made, not when it becomes due.
Why Section 43B Was Introduced
The government noticed a pattern:
- Companies would show huge liabilities like taxes, provident fund (PF), and interest payable but delay payments for years.
- They still claimed tax deductions even without paying.
- Employees and government revenues suffered because of these delays.
Section 43B was introduced to stop this practice.
Importance of Payment-Based Deductions
- Encourages timely payments of statutory dues.
- Protects employees’ rights, especially for PF, ESI, and bonuses.
- Makes businesses more transparent and accountable.
- Prevents misuse of the accrual system for tax evasion.
Understanding the Concept of Payment-Based Deductions
What Are Payment-Based Deductions?
Payment-based deductions are expenses that reduce taxable income only after the money has been paid. Simply “booking” the expense in accounts is not enough.
Example:
- A company owes ₹5 lakh as PF contribution for employees in March 2025.
- If it pays before the due date, it can claim the deduction in AY 2025–26.
- If it delays, deduction will be allowed only in the year of payment.
Accrual-Based vs. Payment-Based Deductions
- Accrual-Based System: Expense is recorded when due, regardless of actual payment.
- Payment-Based System: Expense is recognized only after actual payment.
Section 43B applies only to certain categories of expenses, making them payment-based.
Role in Preventing Tax Evasion
Without Section 43B, companies could keep showing liabilities in their books, claim deductions, but never actually pay employees, banks, or government. This section forces them to clear dues before claiming benefits.
Expenses Covered Under Section 43B
Section 43B specifies certain payments that qualify for deduction only on payment:
1. Taxes, Duties, Cess, and Fees Payable to Government
All statutory payments like GST, excise duty, customs duty, and local taxes are covered. Deduction is allowed only on actual payment.
2. Employer’s Contribution to PF, ESI, and Other Welfare Funds
Employers must deposit contributions to provident fund (PF), employee state insurance (ESI), and other welfare funds by the due date. Deduction is allowed only when paid.
3. Bonus and Commission to Employees
Any bonus, incentive, or commission payable to employees is deductible only after payment.
4. Interest on Loans from Banks, Financial Institutions, and NBFCs
Interest payable on loans or borrowings is deductible only when paid, unless paid before the return filing due date.
5. Leave Encashment Payable
When employees encash unused leaves, the employer must pay them. Deduction is allowed only once the payment is made.
6. Payments to Railways for Freight Services
Expenses payable to Indian Railways for freight and other services fall under Section 43B.
7. Payments to Micro and Small Enterprises (New Clause 43B(h))
From April 1, 2024, businesses must pay MSMEs within 45 days (if agreement exists) or 15 days (if no agreement). Otherwise, deduction is not allowed in that financial year.
Key Conditions for Claiming Deductions
Actual Payment Requirement
No deduction is available until the expense is actually paid.
Due Date for Payment to Claim Deductions
If payment is made on or before the due date of filing Income Tax Return (ITR), deduction can still be claimed in the same year.
Example:
- Employer’s PF due for March 2025, paid in June 2025.
- Since ITR due date is July 31, 2025, the deduction is allowed for AY 2025–26.
Treatment of Advance Payments
If advance payment is made for an expense covered under Section 43B, deduction can be claimed in the year of payment itself.
Impact of Amendments and Recent Updates
Major Amendments Over the Years
- Introduced in 1983.
- Later expanded to cover PF, ESI, bonus, interest, leave encashment.
- 2023 amendment added MSME payments under 43B(h).
Latest Changes Applicable in AY 2025–26
- Payments to MSMEs must be cleared within 45/15 days for deduction.
- Tightened rules around employer contributions to welfare funds.
Practical Implications for Taxpayers
- Businesses must plan cash flow better to ensure payments are made within due dates.
- MSME suppliers will have stronger protection against delayed payments.
Benefits of Section 43B
- Ensures Timely Payment of Statutory Dues
- Protects Employee Interests like PF, bonus, and leave encashment.
- Improves Transparency in financial records.
- Strengthens MSMEs by forcing timely payments.
Challenges and Common Issues
- Cash Flow Problems: Businesses may struggle to pay dues on time.
- Delayed Payments: Leads to disallowance of deduction in that year.
- Compliance Burden: SMEs and startups face extra paperwork.
- Dependence on Digital Tracking: Businesses must rely on software and professional help.
How Businesses Can Ensure Compliance
- Maintain timely bookkeeping and reminders for due dates.
- Use digital tools to track payments.
- Seek professional guidance from chartered accountants and tax advisors.
- Maintain good cash flow management to avoid late payments.
Who Should Pay Special Attention to Section 43B?
- Small Businesses and Startups: Often rely on credit and may delay payments.
- Companies with Large Statutory Dues: E.g., manufacturers with high GST or excise duty.
- Employers with Large Payrolls: Need to deposit PF/ESI on time.
- Businesses Dealing with MSMEs: Must pay within 45/15 days.
Conclusion: Section 43B acts as a watchdog that ensures expenses are deducted from income only when money has actually been paid. It helps in timely clearance of dues, protects employees, and strengthens MSMEs.
Final Advice: Businesses should adopt proper accounting systems, manage cash flow wisely, and ensure all statutory dues are paid on time to avoid disallowances under Section 43B.
Author
